De re Bandwidth Management...

Being a small treatise given at the GLITTER conference in Kalamazoo, Michigan, in March of 2008. Herein I describe our use of dynamic subpartitions for each IP address in our Resnet space, with extra classes to grant special treatment (some good, some bad) to aggressive or fragile traffic types. This presentation describes both Packeteer and Procera Packetlogic configurations.

A small presentation on the Procera Packetlogic given at OARTech in February of 2009. This is an overview, followed by a live demo of Oberlin's system which can't be reproduced here.

Comparing the Procera Packetlogic and the Blue Coat (nee Packeteer) Packetshaper:

There are many differences in configuration and approach used by these two devices. The Packetlogic primarily works by queuing packets through the device, and is very fast about it. One can build shaping rules for minimizing latency, for example. The Packetlogic (software version 11) has network objects, service and protocol objects, firewall and shaping objects, all of which are strung together into shaping or firewall rules which govern the traffic flow through the box.

The Packetshaper (Packetwise software version 8.3), now owned by Blue Coat, manipulates traffic by adjusting window sizes and other TCP/IP parameters to prioritize and partiion traffic by type. It identifies many traffic classes, and permits one to group these classes, partition or prioritize them, and has extensive reporting capability, besides.

At Oberlin, we strive to contain the impact of Peer-to-Peer applications on our network, and we also carve out a little protected space for "fragile" applications like Skype and other voice/video/chat traffic and online game-play. In particular, these applications are sensitive to latency and jitter, and we try to limit that. Interesting then, is this comparison of the particular game and P2P applications identified by each device, using the more current documented information from each at the time I write:

Peer-to-Peer Applications

Games and Game VoIP

PacketWise 8.3
Aimster
Ares
Audiogalaxy

BitTorrent
Blubster

DirectConnect
EarthStationV
eDonkey
eXeem





FileRogue
Filetopia
Furthurnet

Gnutella
Groove
Hopster


Hotline
iMesh



KaZaA





Napster


Pando

PeerEnabler
PPLive



ScourExchange

Share


Soulseek


Tripnosis


Warez

Winny
Winny2
Packetlogic v.11

Ares
Audiogalaxy
Baidu P2P
BitTorrent

Congaltan
DirectConnect

eDonkey
eXeem
ExoSee
FileGurl
FilePia
Foldero
FreePop



Gample
Gnutella


Hanafos QBic
Hardmoa
HotLine
iMesh
IRC DCC transfer
JJangFile
Dakemila
KaZaA
Kontiki
Kor-p2p-generic search
ManoLito
Microsoft BITS
MUTE
Napster
OpenFT transfer
p2pia
Pando
PDBox
PeerEnabler

Perfect Dark
Pruna Plus
Red Swoosh

Secure Content Downloader
Share
Share NT
Soribada
Soulseek
Sunfile
SunFolder

Thunder
V-share

WinMX WPNP
WinNy

Xtoc
ZEPP
ClubBox
ClubFolder
ClubHard
CoolDisk
CrazyFile
DACOM Webhard Client
DiskPop
DiskPot
DiskPump
DiyHard
EA game update
eMusic download
ENdisk
FileBee
FolderPlus
HotDisk
iDisk
iPop
JJandDisk
JJangHard
M-File
MelOn
NeoFolder
NetFolder
OnFile
Peepop
PicoPot
SegaPop
Toto disk
VDisk
WeDisk

PacketWise 8.3













AsheronsCall


Battle.net










CityofHeroes














Doom







Everquest/SonyOnline




















HalfLife







Kali







LucasArts










MSN-Zone
Mythic















Quake





















SonyOnline









Tribes





Unreal












WorldofWarcraft

XBoxLive
YahooGames

VoIP for gamers

Ventrilo
Packetlogic v.11
9Dragons
A Tale in the Desert
A3
Advertising
Age of Armor
Age of Conan
Age of Empires 3
Albatross18
All Seeing Eye
America's Army
Anarchy Online
Angels Online
Archlord
Asheron's Call
Avadetect
Batle for Wesnoth
Battle.net
Battlefield 1942
Battlefield 2
Battlefield 2142
BOTS
Bounty Bay Online
Brettspielwelt client
Cabal Online
Call of Duty
Call of Duty 4
Cheat Prevention
City of Heroes
Civilization 4
Command and Conquer 3
Conquer Online
CorumOnline
Counter-Strike
Crysis
Dance!Online
Dark Age of Camelot
DarkEden
DarkOrbit
Day of Defeat
Decide Online
Diablo 2
Dofus
Doom3
DrakkarZone
Dream of Mirror Online
Dungeon Runners
Dungeons Dragons Online chat
EA:Nation
Enemy Territory: Quake Wars
EVE ONline
EverQuest II
Exteel
Exteel lobby
FEAR
Fiesta
Final Fantasy XI
Fly for Free
Freeciv
Frontlines
FunCom updater
Furcadia
Fury
Gamarena
Game Engines
GameSpy
GameSpy chat
GG Game
Guild Wars
Gun XBox
Gunbound
Gunz
Half-Life
Handheld
Hanagame GoStop
Hero Online
HLSW
Holic
Insurgency: Modern Infantry Combat
Jumpgate

KartRider
Knight online
Last Chaos
Legend of Ares
Lineage
Lineage II
Lord of the Rings

Luminary
Madden 06
Madden 07
Madden NFL 08
Magic Online
Maple Story
Metin2
MixMaster
MU Online
MythWar


Navy Field
NBA Live 07
Neocron 2
Neverwinter Nights
Neverwinter Nights 2
Nexuiz
NHL 07
NHL 08
Nintendo Wi-Fi connection test
OpenArena
Pirates of the Burning Sea
PlayOnline
PlayStation
ProjectEntropia
Puzzle Pirates
Quake 4
Quake III Arena
Rakion
Rappelz revolution
Red Stone
Return to Castle Wolfenstein
RF Online
Ricochet
Rising Eagle
Rubies of Eventide
Runescape
Ryzom
S.T.A.L.K.E.R.
Scions of Fate
Seafight
Second Life
ShadowBane
Shalya
Silkroad Online
Sofnyx
Soldier Front
Soldier of Fortune 2
Sony Station
Source engine
Star Wars Galaxies
Sword of the New World
Tabula Rasa
Tales of Pirates
Team Fortress
Tibia
TimeShift
Titan Quest

Trickster
Turbine
Twelve Sky
Ultima Onliine
Universe at War
Unreal
Unreal 2
Unreal Tournament 3
Upshift StrikeRacer
Vanguard
War Rock
Warcraft 3
Warmonger
WarpFire
Warsow
Wii
WiiConnect 4
World in conflict
World of Warcraft
XBlaster
XBox

Zero Online

TeamSpeak
Ventrilo
Ventrilo udp
Vivox
XBox Live Chat